Carian Retaliation | Elden Ring Wiki

Let it normal parry like the shield AOW variant and I’ll consider. Maybe consider using it. Would look pretty cool to get a parry with a staff. Would be fun in say an dex/frost/scholars armament build. Other than that. AOW works so much better after they fixed it. You can run an entire staff build with a shield, save the spell slot and throw on carian retaliation. Which can then still be buffed by scholars shield.

Submit

This is hot garbage compared to the Ash of War.

Submit

retaliates with gimpblades more like

Submit

Spell is bugged or info here is outdated. With 80 INT and Lusat’s Staff +10, I’m only hitting 479 with all 3 glintblades hitting a Godrick soldier. Should be 3 times damage if each glintblade is supposed to be 1.15*sorcery scaling

Submit

This spell is bugged. Tested on Godrick soldier with 80 int 80 arc albo staff popping my own bubbles for glintblades. Did a whopping 172 damage.

Submit

Unusable in its current condition, should convert the fp of the spells being blocked and add it to your own fp pool.

Submit

invaluable on low level invasions. It one shots any magic spammers.

Submit

does damage increase with sorc scaling?

Submit

How does this compare with Glintblade Phalanx in terms of damage?

Submit

Mt Carian Retaliation is weak asf...whats going on?? 70 int..

Submit

This. Is. The. Spell. There is an Ash of War of the same name. This page is for the spell. You people are dense.

Submit

why do I feel like ash of war hits much harder than the spell? Has anyone tested both in terms of damage and scaling?

Submit

All the comments in here like the comments in all the other sections are about how good it is in pvp. Do any of you actually play the main game? No one talks about how good a weapon or spell is in the actual main game.

Submit

Been trying to get this to work in PvP against spellcasters, faith casters, etc and it just... doesn't work? I'm not sure if I'm just missing timing or if there's a fundamental reason why nothing happens when I use it as a spell is cast at me but it's certainly not reflecting anything when a full Stars of Ruin is cast and I'm certain I was able to use Retaliation (the spell, not the Ash) and nothing happened, I took the full damage...

Submit

THIS IS THE SORCERY. IF YOU ARE HERE TO COMPLAIN ABOUT THE BUG OR GLOAT THAT THE BUG IS GONE, GO HERE: https://eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com/Ash+of+War:+Carian+Retaliation

Submit

What does this AoW scale with? Do I need to upgrade the shield or level up my Int?

Submit

1.04 patch bids you adieu exploiters. I'm still going to run eternal darkness though

Submit

lol its annoying that so many comments are confusing the spell with the ash of war

Submit

So how do I start this class?? I think it’s too late tho since they just updated

Submit

They were pretty quick to nerf Sword of Night and Flame. Hopefully they pick up the pace and patch this nonsense out sooner rather than later. It destroys the entire pvp experience.

Submit

I had no idea how good this was until my second playthrough. I can't believe I can get buckler level parry frames (plus a few more frames) on a medium shield plus rad spell parries. This is awesome!

Submit

Guess this needs to be said. This is the spell version. Not the ash of war version.

Submit

Currently an insta-win button in pvp if you just can’t find yourself good enough to use weapons. Good stuff.

Submit

Do I need to have the Magic Ash of War on my shield? People are saying the parried spell scales only with the level of the shield and my intelligence. So if I spec into a Heavy shield and use Carian Retaliation with like my like 50 intelligence it will still do butt ton of damage?

Submit

so fun to kill mommys lil wizards with it in pvp. they just cant stop spam spells cuz magic looks so grate in this game :D partialy broken yeah. you dont see daggers fly and they remains above enemys head after been used and self proc ofc. but u can see that your spell been reflected, u can dodge daggers and get 0 dmg, and u can block em with carian shield to get low dmg. for comparation you cannot dodge riposte dmg atall.

Submit

Noticed that this changes the buckler's parry animation to a normal parry. Does this mean that using this on a buckler reduces its parry frames, or does it still keep the buckler frames, but gets the normal parry animation instead?

Submit

You can use it on your own rain of stars and magic dawnpour spells

Submit

Which one does more poise damage: the spell version or the ash of war version?

Submit

you can use the spell on the glintstone scrap same way as the shield aow, but it does next to no damage. they are still invisible however, and it makes for hilarious mind games if the other players arent keen

Submit

Works on Godskin's blackflame toss, +24 w/ash of war version shield did ~2500 dmg to the noble in Liurnia, and they used it 3 times in a row.

Submit

Can anyone confirm (preferably with evidence) that the damage of the glintblades scales with the damage of the spell that gets parried?

Submit

It's bugged and can even be used in pvp. You can retaliate your own spell/item and do ~3000 dmg per shot with any +25 shield. It cheeses everything again just like the bugged Erdtree Greatshield, while in pvp the other player can't even see the spell animation this time.

Submit

It's bugged af and can even be used in pvp. You can retaliate your own spell/item and do ~3000 dmg per shot with any +25 shield. Other player can't even see the spell animation.

Submit

Note: this does not work against incantations

Submit

Note: this does not work against incantations

Submit

New cheat/exploit where you can insta kill in pvp using this by parrying your own spells. Needs patched ASAP.

Submit

This is getting a nerf in the near future. If you use a glintstone scrap and PARRY YOUR OWN PROJECTILE, it has been reported to have dealt over 16k damage, one shot on any other player, npc, and a looooot of bosses.

Submit

To be clear: you need to drop down on the south EASTERN side of the three sisters area, simply drop down to where the Manor Lower Level site of grace is.

Submit

some additional info to the wiki: you can also buy it from a merchant called "Pidia, Carian Servant" who is at the upper level of the church in Caria Manor. The one the bonfire "Manor Lower Level" is located, however you enter the upper floor by jumping down from the Three Sisters area. It only costs 3k runes there instead of 9k.

Submit

Everyone saying this sucks has probably been using the spell version, which does piddly damage.

The shield version is broken - been doing 300 ~ 400 per glintblade in PvP at SL 110 with a +12 shield. It's a friggin oneshot. Enjoy it before the nerfs come lol

Submit

Just saw some guy trigger the AoW with his own spell...

Submit

Does it work with against bosses?

Submit

Doesn't work for swarm of flies, good luck countering arcane spammers

Submit

First time i tried this was in ng+7. a centipede's string shots turned into 2100 damage dealt back. the buckler was +24 but still this is damn good for its fp cost!

Submit

Best Anti-ting with any High Magic resistant Shield, wait for any Blue magic dart use Retaliate and insta aggro Mage 90% time one jump shot works in PVP

Submit

Spell version is ****. Shield version does WAY more damage and doubles as a parry.

Submit

I think something in the latest update broke this; the swords aren't doing damage anymore. I remember testing it for the first time against the mage enemies at the academy, and the swords were doing damage to them. Now, when I just tried it again, the spawned swords aren't doing anything at all, except for a moment of minor stagger.

Might be an enemy specific bug, but I'll have to test it against more enemy types to see for sure.

Submit

This spell would work if the glintstone blades would target the enemy mage instantly, but now it is completely useless. I just get barraged and even if I deflect more I dont put more damage into the enemy. Waste of memory and FP. If enemy mages couldn't do anything but fire single glinstone shards, this spell would work. You will get hit anyway by the second barrage of colourful whatevers no matter how good your reaction is.

Submit

Lol what how is everyone saying this sucks this **** destroys mages all the way. It doesn't always destroy their spells but they never see the glintblades coming and at SL133 oneshots Every mage.

Submit

I wish the damage or number of little glintblades you get from this scaled with the enemy spell. Like if it was stone pebble, you’d get one, it was comet you’d get a full phalanx worth

Submit

"This was the Carian royal family's secret means to prepare against the disloyalty of the academy."

No wonder they fell, this spell sucks lmao

Submit

Can be used to counter moonveils projectiles.

Submit

You need to see be able to see the future to use this with this much delay or otherwise youre a god.

Submit

I thought this would be a useful trump card against magic users, but unfortunately it is VERY difficult to use. The timing window is tight, arguably tighter than rolling. The Phalanx-like Glint Blades it summons to retaliate with work similarly to the ones summoned by the Carian Phalanx. This means that they don't shoot back right away and deal minimal damage/stagger, as well as having very low range. Most disappointingly it doesn't work well against a stream of projectiles, a type of magic many enemies use. It CAN absorb multiple projectiles within the brief parry window, but it usually can't be recasted fast enough for a stream of projectiles. Normal Parry attacks justify their stringent timing requirements with massive reward, that of instantly stance breaking an enemy. For this to be useful, it needs to do something similar. For example, if it did something similar to what the Tree Sentinel's Shield did and instantly sent back a massive staggering projectile it would be worth it. Right now it is all the difficulty of parrying with none of the rewards. This is further compounded by the difficulty of picking the right spell you need. You'll never have time to select this spell and use it in the heat of the moment.

Alternatively if this spell either put up a long lasting barrier or was something like blocking for shields, it could also have a niche. As it is, it is pretty unrewarding, you might as well just roll. That, or cast Sorcerous Shield to make your Magic Negation stronger instead.

Let me know if anyone finds good use cases for this spell!

Submit

I tried to use it againt STARSCOURGE RADAHN and it didn't work. Maybe it dosen't work on bosses.

Submit

Sold by Pidia for 3k runes if you drop down from the Three Sisters Area to the ledge right above the Manor Lower Level grace. just follow the ledges down until you get to the point where you cant use your weapons and they are nearby.

Submit

Before going to seluvis at seluvis rise you can fall down off the cliff, onto a tower of the manor. Follow the rough path down into the manor through an opening in the roof to find pidia, Carian Servant. He sells
- 2 budding horn (1500)
- 3 old fang (800)
-2 slumbering egg (600)
- 1 ritual pot (1500)
- 1 celestial dew (5000)
- 1 larval tear (3000)
- 1 Glintstone Craftsman Cookbook [7] (2500)
- 1 Carian retaliation ash of war (3000)
- 1 ripple blade (cool looking axe) (scales only off of arcane) (wild strikes ash of war) (3500)
- 1 black leather shield (no skill basic medium shield) (2500)

No Prerequisite for talking to him and him selling these except for being able to reach him.

Submit

This is sold by Selivus after giving Nephali his potion

Submit

Sold by Preceptor Seluvis at Seluvis's Rise for 9000 runes, after completing his quest. Requires 17 Int and costs 8 FP to cast.

Submit