D's Twin Brother | Elden Ring Wiki

I'm confused in this comment section (I am going under the guise that majority of people here are not women hating incels), but Fia's ending effectively brings actual Death to Lands Between so that there is no such thing as immortality and proper cycle of life and death can occur, correct?

So why are people trying to skew that into saying that it's the bad ending? (Same with Ranni, funny that isn't it how the two endings that have to do with female characters are consistently being painted as the worst endings while the selfsame people parade the Frenzied Flame ending as something good, but I digress).

On the topic of D., while it sucks that Fia had to kill him do people forget the fact that he is a fanatical, zealous mass murderer himself who would spare no thoughts for anything that goes against his cult? He would have most definitely killed Fia in her sleep the moment he learned of who she was so, while once again it sucks he had to be killed, it had to be done.

Submit

i don't get this quest. screw it, just kill everyone

Submit

Screw this guy I liked Fia

Submit

I let him kill Fia (as in, I gave him the armor and didn't murder him preemptively) because she killed his brother, but then I killed him because he was excessively rude about it in my presence. Revenge is one thing, but she's the only person empathetic enough to give you a hug when you need one (I choose to believe the hugs were wholesome), and I won't stand for this sort of insult to my hug provider.

I tried to kill him with Elden Stars because of that line "Honeyed rays of gold, deliver my spirit" but when I cast it I remembered that Elden Stars is not good.

Submit

I really wanted to fight him after he killed Fia to "deliver his spirit", (and to see how tough he was,) but i also really didn't want to kill him cause he helped me kill the gargoyle pair. So after punching him twice i cowarded out and reloaded the area for the loot. Too bad his stats aren't on the page (yet), so i'll actually have to fight him to get a rough estimate of his toughness in the final spot.

Submit

He's so based. He just exists in the game to cause anger to fia simps

Submit

I lov him

Submit

necrophiles seething rn

Submit

Killing him for his gear may be unnecessary but it felt appropriate after he murdered Fia.

Submit

Virgin Fia fan(she's too busy doing it with corpses) vs Chad Golden Order enjoyer (they murdered 5 minorities on the way to work)

Submit

I mean, I would do the same for the person who killed my twin brother. Question is, why is he unarmored and sitting there in the middle of nowhere (remember noone can acess nokron before we kill Radahn!) while his bro is chilling at the Roundtable

Submit

You can watch him blink out of existence after giving him the armor if you turn your camera while going up the stairs. Bro is literally batman

Submit

How can you actually care about lore?

Submit

What a worthless summons

Submit

Him: Look at this rotten w.h.o.r.e. No more children can be got from this useless flesh!
Me: Jesus christ man shes already dead!

Submit

best character

Submit

Based AND Orderpilled

Submit

The people that are angry at this guy taking revenge on Fia who literally murdered his brother and consider her innocent and this guy the devil for it are coping big time

Submit

Those who live in death is like the other side of the coin for Scarlet Rot. Where as one has the afflicted endlessly rotting yet never dying, the other has them fully dead yet somehow living. There's 0 reason to pick this ending, poor Godwyn, you're basically making his rotting fish state official, forever removing any chance of him being saved.

Submit

he is literally me guys

Submit

Wonder if there will be a secret DLC quest if you killed D in Limgrave and then killed his twin brother in the Aqueduct? Since Fia would still be alive maybe we'd be able to meet Godwyn after she resurrects him.

Submit

alfred vibes

Submit

I picked Fia's ending in my first playthrough, it felt like the best course for the people/creatures perpetually living & dying in the ruins of the lands between. Devin killing her didn't really bother me - she murdered his brother, accomplished what she wanted with the rune, he gets revenge. Fair enough lol.

Submit

What people don't seem to realize is that neither fia nor D are doing the right thing. While those who live in death are indeed innocent, they're most likely in constant mental torture(if they can think), since their current state goes completely against the erdtree's intended cycle of life, which is what they were taught to be the only true way of life. Forcing everyone to live in death via fia's ending just means forcing everyone to suffer from constant mental torment.

Submit

I first saw him near fia, and I wasn’t gonna kill him, because I knew her quest line was over anyways, but I saw she died, and she wasn’t even able to defend herself. hearing him gloat and all, I brutally put him to death. No matter what fia did, he had no honor in that fight.

Submit

you can kill him with death blight from fias mist. a very fitting death :)

Submit

Glory to the Golder Order

Submit

Isn't his name Darriwel or something. Blaidd mentions it.

Submit

gotta say, his voice actor did a good job.

Submit

I’m glad everyone cares more about politics than they do about the game. Cause thats what these threads look like, a bunch of politicians who failed in reality so they come on here telling you which side to choose in this game as if they are running for governor of the lands between.

Submit

Bros before hoes

Submit

While D is a cool guy, his gloating twin deserved zero respect, my friends and I all gave him destined death, not to mention he’s weak AF and not even given a boss fight. Loved how the narrative puts into perspective how religious cults like the Golden Order can embolden their fanatic followers to the point of blind hatred against a persecuted group of undead that are the way they are because of the order’s meddling of reality. In Fia’s ending, reality is restored with death introduced, allowing everyone to pass on to the afterlife and no longer become living zombies like the hollowed out wandering nobles. Interestingly, only the tarnished seem sane at this point, while everyone are undead or becoming zombies

Submit

is there a differnce between killing the brother after Fia's death after hearing him gloat or just sitting at the grace where the gear is left behind?

Submit

Down with necrophiles! Glory to the Golden Order

Submit

Is that one guy who botted/alted downvotes and spammed every single anti fia comment with angry replies finally gone?

Submit

Even though neither of them were really doing the right thing, I can respect both D and Fia for at least having the convictions to fight, kill and die for their cause and what they believed was right. On the other hand this dude sleeps in Nokron while his brother is killed, then once he gets his brothers armor he kills a sleeping woman and gloats over her corpse... Idk man I cant really respect that. Which is why I killed him after that.

Basically D is cool, but Ds brother... kind of a crazy loser.

Submit

Based character. I killed fia in my first playthrough before fortisax for stabbing my boy D, found out I missed a boss fight, and then in my next play through the chad does it for me.

Submit

Absolutely did not expect this guy to go full Alfred in the end of the questline

Submit

Heh heh... Behold!
Your favorite character is Dead!

Submit

Regardless of the sins of Darian and Devin, Fia is a genocidal maniac. She hides behind a pitiable guise when the truth is that she wants to force undeath on the entire world. She is not nearly as helpless and she pretends to be. Devin is a creep but killing her was justified.

Submit

If Fia gave him a hug he wouldn’t have been so angry

Submit

Couple of things I've noticed:

Firstly:
- If you never talk to D but do the rest of Fia's questline she dies where she was sleeping and you can loot here clothes. There's no blood pooled around her though.

- Giving D his dead brother's drip and then fast traveling to Prince of Death's throne will still have D standing over Fia's corpse with a blood pool.

This adds some validity to the theory that Fia dies birthing the rune and D is just so eager for revenge that he doesn't notice she's already dead when he stabs her.

Secondly:
- If D dies in Limgrave (either by your hand or collateral from the nearby skeletons) D still hunts down and kills Fia over it. Even though it's not her fault he died.

Guy is so mad at a heretic that he'll kill her for something she hasn't done. Peak zealot moment.

Submit

I just wanna hug
Lmao

Submit

Thanks for the thoroughly entertaining read in these comments, folks (he's still based and goldenpilled)

Submit

WTF is going on in this comment section?

Submit

may chaos take the world

Submit

My man took the gold pill

Submit

Damn I'm an idiot. I thought Darian came back from the dead to exact vengeance. Never that was Devin.

Submit

Just read every comment here and I gotta say it was pretty funny yet also kinda sad

Submit

okey after finishing this quest line, was fia dead or not?
did he just killed an already dead corpse?

Submit

BASE

Submit

my man took the gold pill

Submit

Most relatable Elden Ring character

Submit

wait, fia is already dead at the end of her questline. so did this guy just stab her corpse and pretend he killed her? lol

Submit

this comment section is why people rightfully never interact with fromsoft fandoms

Submit

who the hell sleeps like that

Submit

And probably drink some water

Submit

this comment section needs to touch grass

Submit

This comment section just wants me to do the Frenzy Flame ending again.

Submit

not a fia simp but i always kill him at the end of the quest. that's what i did with alfred's quest, which this one is very reminiscent. both clearly lost it and are too far gone, it just makes sense to put them down. it also just feels a little anticlimactic to have him disappear and leave his stuff behind. what they should've done is have him turn on you after his dialogue since you were helping her in the first place

Submit

Slow day on Reddit, apparently

Submit

Prince of death destroyed the guy. Fia killed his other half/twin brother. Both sides were extremist. He was probably driven mad in his little slumber, didn't sound fun.. Dang straight he wanted to kill her and stop Godwyn from coming back, you killed my brother. Then he was okay with joining him.. no right side here though. Everyone dying was justified.. Living in death destroyed rogie Fia served a monster of a master. She's no better and also an extremists. Great little storyline

Submit

The D stands for downvote

Submit

lol

lmao

Submit

I hope he's still alive after you complete Fia's questline.

Submit

Bro, not people siding with this literal theocratic fundamentalist fascist over a woman who wanted her people liberated. Folks talking about Fia killing Rogier forget that he himself identifies the fact that living within death isn't a sin but a glitch in the system caused by Ranni slaying Godwyn's soul. He even comes back to defend Fia when we reach deeproot depths because he is devoted to seeing the Mending Rune of Death installed in the Elden Ring from before he even dies evidenced by his own musings on the cursemark. D got what was coming to him for being a fantasy nazi and y'all who're siding with his psycho brother in here need therapy. No wonder people **** on our community for being toxic and stupid.

Submit

My boy took the gold pill

Submit

Can't spell Gigachad without the D

Submit

Bruh this comment section is such a mess. Came here for the storyline, stayed for the laughs.

Submit

Thank you for bringing that witch to justice she didn't just enthrall the dead but she has enthralled the living you will be called a fanatic the masses may hate you but you did the right thing I will look to you and your brother's teachings and teach them to others

Submit

I wonder what percentage of the downvote mob here also have reddit accounts.

Submit

A lot of people here don’t understand that fia murdered D for no reason other than getting the half of the curse mark he was guarding, he had no clue she was affiliated with death until she taunted him with his brothers dagger; Because the tarnished are not undead, and neither is fia, she’s a freak that’s condoning and forcing living in death upon others. Look at rogier for example, he gazes upon a fragment of Godwyn once and loses the ability to walk, and then the ability to even think for himself when he is forced to fight in defense of fia; You really think he just suddenly gained the ability to walk and decided to betray us, a person he considered a friend, without so much as a word? Additionally, D knows rogier is afflicted with death blight, but he only offers pity and his own form of remorse, because the hunters of death don’t hunt tarnished, they hunt those affected by death root; meaning UNTHINKING CREATURES, such as tibia mariners and cemetery shades; which is the fate fia is attempting to force upon the world. And notice that no one BUT fia actually wants this; the undead can’t think, godwyn is a soulless husk of his former self, yeah, the golden order isnt full of saints either, but before the shattering it was a certainly better thing, and with gold mask’s help the order could be greater than it ever was. This is all not even mention that what devin does has nothing to even do with the order; It’s simple revenge on the woman that murdered his brother, aside from the fact that he faced godwyn, we know literally nothing about him, he could’ve been a saintly hero or a demonic hunter, but that has nothing to do with his actions now. But no; “Muh evil order!2!1!1!1!”

Submit

Wow... So many people forget about fia killing poor D hunter

Submit

This guy was late to the party.

Submit

If you give him the armor after completing Fia's questline but before fighting the gargoyles (by using the alternate entrance to Deeproot), his summon sign never appears. He just skips straight to his final location in Deeproot.

Submit

I came to peace with Fias philosophy, then this guy shows up and gloats over her corpse like wheel guy from bloodborne
I killed him right after that. don't forget to downvote me.

Submit

Guys, I'm on my first playthrough and don't see the big picture yet. Can anyone please explain what is going on in this comment section? The amount of dislikes is terrific.

Submit

It is worth noting that it is just a video game. I mean there is nothing wrong with playing and enjoying it but I feel like some of you are having trouble separating the game from reality.

Submit

I like to kill him with the Eclipse Shotel, then do the goldmask ending anyways (I only did Fia's questline to fight the cool dragon)

Submit

I like wiener

Submit

I call D and D giga-twins.
This one helps you with the shitty gargoyle duo.
D helps you with the black knife assasin in the catacombs.
Both of them are based as well.
10/10 NPC

Submit

What is this comment section? I've seen many comments here saying things like "D is murder. I wish I could kill him the Moment I saw him and torture him in the most painful way possible!" And other saying things like "Fia is Murderer and an undead apologist who is an objectively bad person. Everyone who defends her is a simp!" I think we should all take a step back to remember that we are speaking about a VIDEO GAME. It is a fictional story with fictional characters who interact with each other in order to progress an optional questline. It's as if everyone in this comment section has engrossed themselves into a fictional world too much and get so attached to either the D brothers or Fia. The result is that everyone in the comments is warring over whether Fia or D are morally correct in their actions and yelling at each other because whenever an NPC they like gets attacked they feel personally offended and obligated to argue back.

I'm not saying it's wrong to discuss lore or even the morality of these characters' actions. What I am saying is that if we are to discuss these things we need to remember we are talking about fiction here and speak about them like rational and mature, sane human-beings. So please, for the sake of your own health, Ya'll should go touch some grass.

Submit

he agroed on me after giving the twined set, even tho it was obtained by doing Fia's questline

Submit

i for one think the game is good

Submit

I don't know why anyone would choose to simp for Fia after killing D. Her useless baldichins are nothing to the help he gives. The golden order are right in not wanting a bunch of skeletons walking around the world. If you want the best future, you should kill Fia yourself instead of helping her.

Submit

undead apologist vs golden order enjoyer

Submit

Most based character in elden ring, I really wish his quest was longer. D is too cool to have such a short quest line.

Submit

For what reason is that cool pose he does after murdering fia not a gesture you can get

Submit

Challenge: write something positive about Devin without getting downvoted to oblivion (difficulty: impossible)

Submit

I killed Fia at the prince of deaths throne after she murdered D, I gave D's brother the armor set after that and when I reloaded the area, he had disappeared, where did he go? I can't find him at Fia's location

Submit

Love this character. A true Hero of the Golden Order.

Submit

I feel like D brothers questline should've been a bit longer, because I still don't understand how tf Devin gotten into a Nokron of all places, a city that is closed off to everyone. even PC can get there after a frickin meteorite falls somewhere close to it. so was Devin a part of expedition ? then why he doesn't look like those skinny white dudes ? was he trapped there ? is this why he needs his brother armor ? so he can remember who is he because he was trapped there for so long ? and how tf he has a sword identical to his twin brother ?

Submit

So this comment section must be what it feels like to be pkcs guy

Submit

Please downvote me as much as possible.

Submit

ah yes this must be the dislike npc

Submit

d my bro *handshake*

Submit

Love this guy, he gives me alfred vibes.

Submit

Skeleton apologist vs Crusade enjoyer

Submit

He's not really killing her, so why write about it??? "after he kills Fia".

Submit

Damn I wish their was an option to say sorry but your brother had cool looking armor so I needed to kill him.

Submit