Messages allow players to place messages that have a random chance (?) to be seen on the ground by other players where they are placed. The text in messages can only be selected from premade words and phrases, but the format of a message being written can be toggled by pressing a button (default is the Y button on an Xbox controller) for more complex fields. The hard formatting of messages allows them to be automatically translated and displayed in different regions around the world.
They have some unique mechanics compared to their counterparts in FromSoftware titles.
Appraisals
A player reading a message can rate it Good or Bad as an Appraisal. When a message is rated Good, the author will receive 1 Flask of Crimson Tears' worth of health at no cost.
A player can see Good vs Bad ratings on their messages, but only the number of Appraisals will be shown on messages from other players.
Full message list
Templates
**** ahead | Likely **** | If only I had a ****... | ****, O **** | Ahh, ****... |
No **** ahead | First off, **** | Didn't expect ****... | Behold, ****! | **** |
**** required ahead | Seek **** | Visions of ****... | Offer **** | ****! |
Be wary of **** | Still no ****... | Could this be a ****? | Praise the ****! | ****? |
Try **** | Why is it always ****? | Time for **** | Let there be **** | ****... |
Words
Enemies |
|
|
|
|
|
People |
|
|
|
|
|
Things |
|
|
|
|
|
Battle Tactics |
|
|
|
|
|
Actions |
|
|
|
|
|
Situations |
|
|
|
|
|
Places |
|
|
|
|
|
Directions |
|
|
|
||
Body Parts |
|
|
|
||
Affinities |
|
|
|
|
|
Concepts |
|
|
|
|
|
Phrases |
|
|
|
|
|
Conjunctions
- and then
- or
- but
- therefore
- in short
- except
- by the way
- so to speak
- all the more
- ,
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
For anyone wondering: you can only have a max of 10 messages active at one point, any other message you create after that will replace your oldest one
- Anonymous
>sees cotton item in the world on a dead body
>leave message: "vigor!,
Praise the south!"
>game of the year
- Anonymous
You should unlock one level up for every note appraisal. One flask worth of health is not much, and the chances of you being online and in battle when your note is appraised is very unlikely. Maybe there could be a one day cooldown, but I think it’s be nice if you got some sort of token that lets you level up once.
- Anonymous
Anyone else accidentally rate a message bad while trying to access inventory?
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
why no torch in the words line? cmon man! i wanna say "Try beast, torch" in front of a bunch of rats
- Anonymous
It is truly hilarious, give people some random phrases and everybody creates the funniest or dumbest messages. Had good laughs with some messages. :)
Albeit, they removed some entertaining dual-purpose words for sex-related messages, so the latently horny gamer souls have a harder time to communicate their lust.
My DS2 favorites: in front of the stone trader in Majula "tight spot ahead, therefore man required ahead"
and for Milfanito "try first tongue, then rear"
- Anonymous
I've just realized that there is no way to refer to Red Phantoms in this menu. In DS1 you could refer to enemy invaders as "Darkwraith" because that was the most prominent PvP covenant. I've forgotten if DS2 or DS3 have something similar, but regardless I'm kind of disappointed, because it would be useful to mark areas with NPC Invaders. I've taken to using the "wraith" fill-in as a substitute, but it'd be nice to get an update to the messaging system to include more keywords so that I don't have to abstract my messages, and can say what I actually mean.
- Anonymous
They should take the animation off putting messages down, or at least let you roll out of it. Shouldn't end up getting punished for attempting to be helpful, that's just seriously toxic
- Anonymous
when do i get the right?
thats the neat part, you don't have the right, o, you don't have the right
- Anonymous
you don't have the right, o, you don't have the right, therefore you don't have the right, o, you don't have the right
- Anonymous
literally only get positive ratings after using a healing flask
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
I personally think that when someone rates a message as bad, it should disappear from their world. Not from everybody's world, but only from the world of the one who disparaged it. Nor should a bad rating punish the one who left the message in any way. That's too easy for trolls to abuse. That would make it much more engaging and satisfying to engage with the message system.
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
Yes, I do pay $25 for PS+ only to see "Hidden Path Ahead, Try Attacking" At a random stone wall
- Anonymous
messages still not showing up for all group password users, message appraisals still only updating when first logging on, just in general the message system is ******* broken
- Anonymous
several questions here, A. is there a limit to how many messages a single character can have written? B. is there a limit to how many written messages i can have protected? C. if a written message is not protected, will it go away after a while? if so what are the qualifications for it disappearing? thanks
- Anonymous
several questions here, A. is there a limit to how many messages a single character can have written? B. is there a limit to how many written messages i can have protected? C. if a written message is not protected, will it go away after a while? if so what are the qualifications for it disappearing? thanks
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
Quick question, if I summon someone to my game and lay a message down, are they able to read it? Wondering if theres a quick way to communicate with players outside of gestures and the Prattling Pates
- Anonymous
seek precious thing, so to speak dog (in front of a turtle(dog))
- Anonymous
Wish there was a phrase along the lines of "what a thrill".
It would be posted by every ladder in the game.
- Anonymous
O you don't have the right, o you don't have the right, by the way you don't have the right, o you don't have the right.
- Anonymous
It would really be awesome if you could collect extra phrases and/or templates out in the world somewhere. You already collect gestures and recipe books... why not optional words?
- Anonymous
There is a typo in the Things category in column 3:
mao, which should be map instead
- Anonymous
bro i had the best message in mind at the uhh evergaol in the snow region (sentry, torch required ahead) and then there's no torch in the message list but sentry is there like WHAT i'm so sad
Downvoting a message does NOT heal them! It doesn't even give a notification. Here's my test result: https://old.reddit.com/r/Eldenring/comments/tvz2jv/may_this_short_clip_settle_the_debate_once_and/
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
Give the option of manually closing messages so I can take screenshots without messages ruining the aesthetic
- Anonymous
I feel like the Yik Yak solution of removing messages that have a surplus of downvotes could work well in this game. Maybe a two to one ratio of Poor to Good with a minimum amount of votes could make a message disappear
- Anonymous
I feel like the Yik Yak solution of removing messages that have a surplus of downvotes could work well in this game. Maybe a two to one ratio of Poor to Good with a minimum amount of votes could make a message disappear
- Anonymous
Is the amount of healing from appraisals just a flat amount or does it scale with your flask upgrades or the flask-boosting talisman?
- Anonymous
I wish every 5-10 bad ratings caused you to lose a flask's worth of health. Maybe then we wouldn't have so many fake illusory wall messages.
- Anonymous
can we please STOP PUTTING MESSAGES AT THE FOOT OF LADDERS!!! IT IS NOT FUNNY WHEN YOUR TRYING TO RUN TO SAFTY!!
- Anonymous
I just witnessed the appraisal healing essentially grant godmode to a streamer because their viewers were giving a message good ratings every 2 seconds.
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
For me, the Conjunctions "or," "except" and "in short" always display without a space between the the Conjunction and Templates (2nd Line). Anyone else? If it's a general problem I'm surprised they haven't patched it yet. I'm also finding that I miss some of the Conjunctions that were available in Sekiro, like "is," "the pinnacle of," "what is a...?" Hopefully From improve the Messages system with upcoming patches.
- Anonymous
Can someone link the messages page with the one on the Tarnished Wizened Finger page so those who find that page can have some answers. Also, some more info.... the messages glow after a certain amount of votes (The precise amount and color is unknown to me but I've seen gold at 541 and I have a silverish gold at 278), the max you can have is 10 messages at once and after that it starts deleting the oldest message that isn't protected. Might wanna throw a note in there about how common troll messages are in FromSoft games as a joke to save some sanity for newer players.
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
This page is sorely lacking, it needs to have the catagories for a quick ctrl + F because i swear to god i forget where certain words are and this would be more constuctive than FromSoft's inability to do a reasonable system
- Anonymous
For the love of all things sacred STOP LEAVING MESSAGES AT THE EDGES OF BOSS FOG WALLS!
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
- Anonymous
Does someone know if there is a maximum amount of messages you can place?
- Anonymous
I created this page because of the estus rating thing, but I'm not sure whether it only happens for Good ratings or both Good and Bad.
Also this page would be a great place to elaborate on message construction, but I only know how to form two-phrase messages as opposed to some of the more complex stuff I've seen. This would be a great place to elaborate on that.
*Praise the message, O, Praise the message*
0
+10
-1